As soon as Braves catcher Sean Murphy went down with an injury, it became clear that top prospect Drake Baldwin would get a serious shot at the starting catcher role. Determined to prove he was ready, Baldwin entered spring training with purpose and has impressed, batting .333 with an .844 OPS over 13 games.
As the Braves gradually trimmed their roster over the past few weeks, Baldwin continued to stick around in big league camp. With Monday’s news that Atlanta had cut Curt Casali and Sandy León, it all but guaranteed that Baldwin would be heading into the season with the Braves.
Now, the focus shifts to the backup catcher role. While incumbent Chadwick Tromp was a strong candidate, the Braves opted to bring in veteran experience, agreeing to a minor league deal with James McCann.
Braves sign catcher James McCann to minor league deal
At first glance, this move might seem discouraging for those hoping to see Baldwin as the Braves’ primary catcher. However, Atlanta understands that Baldwin lacks experience, and adding a veteran like McCann—who can manage a pitching staff and has contributed offensively in recent years—provides valuable support. Plus, since McCann hasn’t participated in spring training yet, he’s unlikely to immediately take away Baldwin’s playing time.
This move also makes sense when considering the long-term plan for when Murphy returns from the IL. Unless Baldwin goes on an incredible hot streak to start the season, Murphy will likely reclaim the primary catcher role, and Baldwin will be sent back to the minors for regular playing time.
Signing McCann now provides Atlanta with insurance not only if Baldwin struggles but also in case Murphy faces any setbacks. Additionally, it gives the Braves flexibility to ease Murphy back into action when he returns. Since McCann’s deal is of the minor league variety, it carries no real risk—Atlanta can evaluate his performance in the minors before making any further commitments.
When the Braves were initially connected to the free-agent catching market, some speculated it signaled doubts about Baldwin’s MLB readiness. However, this move—especially as a minor league deal for McCann—seems more like a smart insurance policy for a playoff-contending team. With Murphy sidelined and Baldwin making his big-league debut, Atlanta is simply ensuring they have depth at the position.
