The New York Yankees underwent a significant overhaul this offseason, despite their World Series appearance. The team witnessed several key free agents depart and traded away notable players to pave the way for fresh talent. One such trade involved 2022 All-Star Jose Trevino, who was shipped off to the Cincinnati Reds in exchange for relief pitcher Fernando Cruz. This move allowed the Yankees to bolster their bullpen and clear approximately $3.5 million in salary, which was Trevino’s projected arbitration figure.
However, it didn’t take long for Trevino to secure a more substantial payday. In a move that may raise eyebrows among Yankees fans, the Reds signed Trevino to a three-year extension worth around $15 million on Thursday afternoon. While Trevino was undoubtedly a fan favorite during his time with the Yankees, his declining performance couldn’t be ignored. His batting prowess regressed significantly, potentially due to injuries or a one-off exceptional season in 2022. Furthermore, his shoulder issues led to a substantial decline in arm strength.
The Yankees’ decision to part ways with Trevino, deeming him unworthy of a $3.5 million salary for 2025, raises questions about the Reds’ decision to invest $15 million in him. Given the Reds’ status as a small-market club, this move seems puzzling, especially considering Trevino’s recent struggles. The Yankees, known for not always making the most prudent personnel decisions, seem to have dodged a costly commitment in this instance.
Former Yankees catcher Jose Trevino signs contract extension with Reds
Congratulations are indeed in order for Jose Trevino, who has carved out a valuable role as a backup catcher in MLB since 2018. As he enters his age-32 season, Trevino was due for a significant payday, and he’s secured one with the Reds. His hard work has earned him this opportunity, and it’s a testament to his dedication. Trevino’s defensive skills, particularly his ability to block pitches and frame strikes, remain among the best in the league.
However, his limitations are also clear. Trevino struggles with pop time and throwing out runners, and his offense has declined sharply, with a .212 batting average and just 12 homers over his last 128 games. The Reds’ decision to extend Trevino may be driven by his experience and potential to mentor younger players. Alternatively, the team may be seeking additional security at the catcher position, given the uncertain status of contract extension talks with Tyler Stephenson.
Ultimately, the Reds have secured their desired catcher, and Trevino has received a substantial contract. While the Yankees’ decision not to pay Trevino $3.5 million for one year raises questions, the Reds’ willingness to invest over triple that amount for three years is a puzzling contrast.
