After another disappointing season, the New York Giants have made bold moves to try to rebound. However, notable weaknesses still exist on both sides of the ball. General manager Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll are under heavy scrutiny to return the Giants to playoff contention. While they have addressed some roster needs through free agency, there’s still significant work to be done. To build a sustainable contender, New York must make one more critical move—one that could be painful in the short term but is essential for their long-term success.
Giants Free Agency Recap: A Mixed Bag of Moves
The Giants took a proactive approach in free agency, prioritizing improvements to their defense following a challenging 2024 season. Recognizing the need for reinforcements, they brought in promising young defensive backs Paulson Adebo and Jevon Holland. Both players offer significant upside and are expected to play key roles in 2025. Additionally, defensive lineman Roy Robertson-Harris was signed to add depth to a run defense that struggled last season.
On the offensive side, the New York Giants have addressed their ongoing quarterback issues by signing Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston. While this duo provides more stability than last season’s disastrous QB rotation, the solution feels more like a short-term fix rather than a long-term solution. Wilson, in particular, is an upgrade, but his one-year contract indicates that head coach Brian Daboll and general manager Joe Schoen are prioritizing immediate survival rather than securing a true franchise quarterback.
If the Giants fail to land one of the top quarterback prospects in the upcoming NFL Draft, they may find themselves in a challenging position. While Wilson might bring some short-term wins, the Giants are still likely to miss the playoffs and remain without a clear long-term plan. As a result, the team will need to continue building depth in various areas to ensure future success.
The Perfect Trade the Giants Must Complete After the 2025 NFL Free Agency Frenzy
After addressing some of their immediate needs in free agency, the Giants should now turn their focus to the trade market. One ideal trade would involve moving star edge rusher Kayvon Thibodeaux to a team in need of pass-rushing help, like the New Orleans Saints, in exchange for valuable draft capital.
While trading away a young and talented player like Thibodeaux might seem counterproductive for a rebuilding team, it could be a smart long-term move. The Giants could use the draft capital from such a trade to secure a potential franchise quarterback or cornerstone offensive lineman—positions that are crucial for building a sustainable contender. By reinvesting their resources wisely, the Giants could accelerate their rebuild and set themselves up for a brighter future.
Ultimately, while the Giants’ quarterback situation remains uncertain, making bold and strategic moves in both free agency and the trade market could help them lay the foundation for long-term success.
