The Braves need to find a long-term solution for their shortstop position. While they might consider bringing Orlando Arcia back as the starter next year, it would merely be a temporary fix, as he’s not the answer. Unfortunately, free agent options are scarce.
Willy Adames stands out as the top shortstop available, but he’s poised for a significant contract. As an All-Star caliber player at a key position, he’s hitting free agency at an ideal time. If Ha-Seong Kim decides to stay with the Padres, Adames may be the only starting-caliber shortstop available, which will likely spark a bidding war for his talents.
Typically, the Braves don’t participate in such bidding wars, and it’s unrealistic to expect that to change this offseason. A more plausible route for Alex Anthopoulos would be to explore trade possibilities, a strategy he often employs to enhance the roster.
Like free agency, the trade market has limited options, but two names are worth monitoring:
**Bo Bichette**
The two-time All-Star was a frequent topic during the trade deadline, with the Braves linked to him. However, the Blue Jays decided to keep him. Toronto’s direction this offseason is uncertain. Once seen as a potential World Series contender, their young talent has underperformed, resulting in a disappointing 74-88 record this year, landing them last in the AL East.
It might be time for the Blue Jays to rebuild. Bichette, who struggled last season and posted career-low stats, could still attract interest due to his age and previous performance, including a top 16 finish in AL MVP voting from 2021-2023. His contract, with only one year left at $17 million, is also manageable.
While the Braves could be interested, Bichette’s defensive play at shortstop has declined significantly, and players typically don’t improve defensively as they age.
**Nico Hoerner**
Hoerner is likely the more appealing option for the Braves. He’s a stronger defensive player and has two years left on his contract, with salaries of $11.5 million next year and $12 million in 2026. That’s a reasonable rate for a starting shortstop, especially since he’s accumulated at least 3.9 fWAR over the past three seasons.
Although not a powerhouse at the plate, Hoerner is solid offensively and doesn’t strike out often. His 94 stolen bases over the last three seasons could address the Braves’ struggles in that area, particularly after Ronald Acuña Jr. was injured.
However, two challenges may arise in pursuing a trade for Hoerner. The Cubs, despite being a subpar team, have actively sought improvements in recent years, making it unlikely they’d trade him. Even if they’re open to negotiation, he won’t come cheap, and several teams will likely be interested, while the Braves’ farm system lacks depth.
