The New York Yankees’ offseason has been a whirlwind. While fans were understandably disappointed by Juan Soto’s move to Queens, the team’s swift and effective implementation of a strong backup plan has positioned Aaron Boone’s squad well.
The Yankees’ roster is undeniably loaded with talent. Max Fried strengthens a revamped rotation alongside Gerrit Cole, and Devin Williams steps in as the reliable closer the 2024 team previously lacked. On offense, Cody Bellinger and Paul Goldschmidt are poised to contribute significantly, though neither is expected to match the towering impact of their $765 million predecessor.
The Yankees are adopting a by-committee approach to move forward without Juan Soto, which is the most sensible strategy. Fortunately for concerned fans, Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman have spared no expense following Soto’s departure. Instead, they’re focused on building on their World Series run and establishing a sustainable contender for the future.
Here’s the latest buzz from the Yankees organization as their whirlwind offseason continues to unfold.
Yankees lineup with Paul Goldschmidt looks a bit less potent than before
Last season, the Yankees’ offense functioned more like a two-cylinder engine, heavily reliant on Aaron Judge and Juan Soto to shoulder the load for an otherwise average lineup. However, the addition of multiple impactful bats this offseason is a promising sign. Cody Bellinger and Paul Goldschmidt bring proven middle-of-the-lineup experience, while Jazz Chisholm’s first full season with the team is expected to make a significant difference.
That being said, early projections for the Yankees’ 2025 lineup are underwhelming.
Having Paul Goldschmidt bat cleanup would have been ideal three years ago, but the veteran first baseman is clearly in decline. Last season, he posted a .245/.302/.414 slash line, marking the lowest slugging percentage of his career. While the 37-year-old did finish the season on a high note after a sluggish start, injuries and the inevitable effects of aging are likely to take a toll on his performance in 2025.
Adding to the concern is Cody Bellinger’s recent season, where his slugging numbers also took a significant dip. While the combined talent of Goldschmidt and Bellinger is undeniable, neither player is as dependable or as productive as they were during their peak years.
Some might suggest that Aaron Judge should bat second or even leadoff, with the idea that placing Cody Bellinger ahead of Judge could create a more balanced lineup. There’s no shortage of adjustments that could be made, but no matter how the lineup is arranged, Juan Soto’s absence will undoubtedly leave a significant void.
Yankees tried — and failed — to trade Marcus Stroman for Nolan Arenado
The Yankees reportedly tried to trade Marcus Stroman for Nolan Arenado, according to MLB.com’s John Denton, Bryan Hoch, and Mark Feinsand, but their offer was quickly rejected. Stroman’s contract, which includes a $18.3 million salary for 2025 and a vesting option for 2026, was likely a major obstacle in the negotiations.
One could question the St. Louis Cardinals’ strategy in this situation, given that Arenado’s contract will pay him $52 million over the next three years. While Stroman’s deal might seem like dead weight, it expires sooner, potentially offering the Cardinals more long-term financial flexibility. However, Arenado continues to deliver considerable value as a Gold Glove third baseman and solid hitter. On the other hand, Stroman had a rough 2024 season, with a demotion to the bullpen and a noticeable absence from the postseason.
St. Louis is unlikely to trade Arenado for nothing, as they would expect some value in return. However, the Yankees’ pursuit of Arenado isn’t off the table, according to the MLB.com report. There’s speculation within league circles that the arrival of Paul Goldschmidt could play a significant role in Arenado’s decision on whether to waive his no-trade clause and move to New York.
Arenado’s contract is hefty, but given that the Yankees are in the largest market in baseball, they have little reason to operate on a budget. With the right trade package, St. Louis could be convinced to help cover part of Arenado’s salary, easing the financial burden on Brian Cashman and the front office. A reunion of Arenado and Goldschmidt could significantly boost New York’s chances of returning to the top.
Yankees could emerge as favorites to land Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
There’s a scenario where the Blue Jays and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. could reach a new contract, as Guerrero has expressed his love for Toronto. However, with the vast amounts of money flowing in free agency, it’s highly unlikely that he’ll avoid the open market. Guerrero is expected to test the waters and offer his services to the highest bidder next winter, putting the Blue Jays at a clear disadvantage.
The question for Toronto is whether to trade Guerrero now for a prospect haul or risk losing him next offseason for nothing. Regardless of the path the Blue Jays take, the Yankees are lurking as a potential destination. While Guerrero once famously stated he would never play for New York, he has since softened his stance—likely a savvy business move considering the opportunities in a major market like New York.
Guerrero’s next contract could easily surpass $500 million in today’s market. While the Yankees have already spent heavily this winter, missing out on Juan Soto leaves room for another major superstar acquisition in the future. Stephen Parello of Rising Apple suggests that a Yankees-Mets bidding war could unfold in 2025, with Guerrero as the main prize. Like Soto, Guerrero will enter free agency at the peak of his prime, bringing a rare combination of longevity, power, and plate discipline. It’s a scenario that would certainly make for an exciting and highly competitive offseason.
