The suggestion that the San Francisco 49ers should trade star wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk to the Buffalo Bills comes with some major considerations. The proposal is framed from the Bills’ perspective, noting that while Buffalo was one of the top offensive teams last season, they still lacked a true No. 1 receiver. Despite solid contributions from players like Khalil Shakir and rookie Keon Coleman, the Bills haven’t had the breakout receiver they need to get over the hump, especially with past trade attempts like the Amari Cooper deal falling short.
Pro Football Network suggests that Aiyuk could be the solution to Buffalo’s deep-field struggles, especially with Josh Allen’s struggles on deep passes in recent seasons. However, the trade’s feasibility for the 49ers is questionable. Aiyuk is recovering from an ACL and MCL injury, which raises concerns about his readiness for the upcoming season and, in turn, his trade value. Additionally, PFN fails to mention what the 49ers would receive in return, making it hard to assess the trade’s validity. On top of that, Aiyuk’s new four-year contract, with a significant $39.2 million dead cap hit in 2025, complicates the financial aspect for the 49ers.
The idea of trading San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk to the Buffalo Bills presents significant challenges. The proposal comes from the Bills’ perspective, where despite a strong offensive performance last season, they still lack a true No. 1 receiver. While players like Khalil Shakir and rookie Keon Coleman contributed, Buffalo hasn’t found the breakout receiver they need, and past trade attempts (like the Amari Cooper trade) didn’t work out.
Pro Football Network suggests that Aiyuk could solve Buffalo’s deep-field issues, especially with Josh Allen’s struggles on deep passes. However, from the 49ers’ side, the trade raises several concerns. Aiyuk is recovering from ACL and MCL injuries, which adds uncertainty about his readiness for the upcoming season and his trade value. Additionally, PFN doesn’t specify what the 49ers would get in return, making it hard to evaluate the trade’s potential. Aiyuk’s four-year contract also comes with a hefty $39.2 million dead cap hit in 2025, making it financially challenging for the 49ers.
While the deal might benefit the Bills, it’s unclear if it makes sense for the 49ers, given Aiyuk’s injury and the financial implications.
In summary, while the trade could benefit the Bills, it’s unclear if it’s a smart move for the 49ers, especially with Aiyuk’s injury status and the financial impact on their cap.
